Pizza Brothers

Discover delicious NY-style pizza, garlic knots, cannolis, and more at Pizza Brothers in Auburndale, FL. Experience a cozy atmosphere with crispy dough, stuffed pizzas, and flavorful Italian dishes. Call +1 863-229-5760 for your next meal!

Welcome to Pizza Brothers

Experience the finest dining

Pizza Brothers
Pizza Brothers
Pizza Brothers
Pizza Brothers

Pizza Brothers stands out in Auburndale for its hearty slices and welcoming vibe. Nestled at 213 E Lake Ave, this local gem specializes in New York-style pizza, drawing fans from across the area. The smell of freshly made dough wafts through the air, mingled with hints of garlic from their signature garlic knots. Couples and families alike gather here for cozy dinners, making every meal feel like a special occasion. Whether you're grabbing a slice or lounging with a cannoli, Pizza Brothers creates an inviting atmosphere that caters to all tastes.

Pizza Brothers offers an extensive menu filled with mouthwatering options. The focus remains on their pizza, featuring choices from classic cheese to stuffed varieties that pack a punch. Appetizers like crispy mozzarella sticks and bacon cheese fries get diners ready for their meal. The restaurant also boasts a selection of wings and delicious baked pasta, balancing the menu and satisfying diverse cravings. Specialties include penne vodka and chicken parmigiana, showcasing Italian flavors that impress. With affordable prices around an average of $20 per plate, everyone can indulge without breaking the bank.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

213 E Lake Ave, Auburndale, FL 33823, United States

Phone

+1 863-229-5760

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Pizza Brothers
Pizza Brothers
Pizza Brothers
Pizza Brothers

Established as a community favorite, Pizza Brothers is dedicated to delivering quality food with a personal touch. Located in the heart of Auburndale, the restaurant attracts both locals and visitors looking for delicious pizza and a friendly atmosphere. Guests rave about the crispy dough and generous portions, often emphasizing their love for the stuffed pizzas, packed with flavorful fillings. Garlic knots and meatball appetizers draw patrons in, and many dine here during the bustling peak hours on Fridays, where they often experience a full house.

Yet, the restaurant also knows how to balance busy times with laid-back moments, making lunch a pleasant experience with 35.2% popularity during the day. Families enjoy dining together as they explore a range of options, from personal pizzas to larger 16” pies perfect for sharing. Pizza Brothers focuses on community and connection, making each dining experience personal. Regular days can feel casual, but the energy spikes during the weekend, highlighting the restaurant's social appeal.

Culinary enthusiasts love that Pizza Brothers offers well-prepared dishes, coupled with outstanding customer service. It's not just a meal; it’s an event that draws strangers into friends over flavorful dishes. This establishment understands culinary traditions while embracing creativity, constantly evolving their menu to include fresh and exciting offerings. No matter how busy or quiet the dining period, the emphasis on taste, quality, and community shines brighter than any busy-night crowd. Those seeking the best pizza experience in town regularly return for memorable nights shared over slices and laughter.

Pizza Brothers

From the outside, Pizza Brothers exudes a warm and welcoming charm. The brick façade and bright signage capture attention, drawing in both locals and passersby. The outdoor seating adds to the inviting atmosphere, perfect for enjoying a slice on a sunny Auburndale day. Inside, the cozy décor invites guests to relax and savor their meals. The laid-back vibe encourages conversation as family and friends share laughter and great food.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday11 AM-9 PM
  • Monday11 AM-9 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

First time ordering since its change and I have 2 say this pizza reminds me alot of new york. (Back Home to me) highly recommended. Large pepperoni n a personal size no cheese pepperoni we ordered. 10/10 highly recommended. Great job pizza brothers we will be back for more. This is an authentic pizzeria

F
Frances R.

I absolutely love Pizza Brothers. I CRAVE their Calzones and garlic knots all the time. A wide variety on the menu. Prices are reasonable. Definitely check them out!

S
Serena J.

We had stuffed pizza and both were perfect. We have tried different things in past and all perfect. The brothers are friendly too. Stuffed pizza is pizza size. These are how I sliced it. We had 10 inch. We tried the chicken bacon ranch pizza and it's so good too.

S
Security C.

My husband and I entered the building and we were welcomed with love. This place feels so cozy and the food was immaculately prepared and if I could refer you to a meal, I'd say order a bit of a few things. We ate supreme pizza, vodka pasta, rolls, Ceaser salad, and boy oh boy it was so much we had to take it home....... Don't forget to come for the lunch specials..... ...... you will not be disappointed..... Authenticity matters

L
Latoya B.

Went inside to give it a try after consistently passing it and they did not disappoint. Great pizza, great atmosphere, great vibes, and the staff are all genuine people who you can tell take pride in their work. Would highly recommend this places to others! The pizza is the best fresh pizza I've ever had along with the homemade tiramisu!

C
Carlos R.

Best pizza we've found in this area! The Philly pizza is our go to. The meatballs are better than your mother used to make (of you actually had a mother that cooked). Highly recommended!

T
Tee V.